Growing up in Petoskey, Michigan fostered in me a healthy dislike of small towns. And when I say “healthy” I mean “strong,” “passionate,” “burning.” Strong words, I know, but when I finished high school I drove away with the windows down, toward the promise of a life unencumbered by the quiet narrow mindedness I had always perceived to be there. (*An important note* The longer I’ve been away, the more I miss my hometown. Northern Michigan has become a haven for me, a place that I can’t wait to get back to as soon as I leave. It all adds to the dilemma of “where now?” More on that in later posts.)
Funny thing though…I didn’t get far from small-town life. Looking at schools, New York (where my mom’s family is from) seemed too gritty, too full of concrete. Chicago had too many clean lines and busy streets for my taste, and L.A. or San Francisco was just too far away. And so I found myself in Ann Arbor at the University of Michigan’s Residential College and then the School of Social Work for grad school. Ann Arbor is a relatively small city that nourished the small-town girl that I couldn’t yet acknowledge was completely, totally me. It was an awesome experience. Wonderful professors. Interesting, creative, talented classmates. Eye-opening in that I was not the big fish I once thought, but in fact a minnow among millions of very smart, talented minnows in an ocean full of fishes of all sizes, shapes, colors…
When school was over, it came time to decide where to go next. I had an aching desire to get out of Michigan, mostly because all of my friends were, but found myself in a job that I loved, tutoring and mentoring elementary and middle-schoolers in an economically depressed area of metro-Detroit. With many of my closest friends gone back to New York, D.C., and overseas, Ann Arbor had lost much of its luster. Simon and I decided to move together to Ferndale, just north of Detroit. We thought it would be an interesting experiment, staying in Michigan despite the struggling economy, plummeting housing market, and shrinking population.
We’ve now been in Ferndale almost three years and love it. We are within biking distance of grocery stores, bars, shopping, a farmer’s market, three libraries, concerts, parks and green spaces, friends, and his family. We live in a small town with easy access to the big city down Woodward Avenue. When it came time to renew our lease, we explored the idea of moving to Detroit. Many of our friends had moved there, found interesting jobs and beautiful apartments, and were making pretty wonderful lives for themselves. After lots and lots of deliberating, we decided to stay in Ferndale for a number of reasons, mostly work-related. But, we’re not sure where we’d like to “settle down” when the time comes. Somewhere between the back and the front of our minds is The Detroit Question: should we move to the city or stay in the ‘burbs?
This week, this article was featured in the New York Times. It describes a number of initiatives aimed at bringing young entrepreneurs and artists to live and work in the city, and compares Detroit’s revival to that in Berlin in the 90’s. Using words like “hip,” “creative,” “dedicated,” and “young” to describe the folks moving into the city, I can’t help but wonder, “Hey, we’re all of those things. Are we missing out?”
I think about what my friends are doing – urban farming, making films, working with schools to incorporate local, organic produce into their menus, playing music, selling home-preserved food and teaching classes, legal advocacy, and so on – I feel like I should join the “movement.” Not only is the activity in the city really, really exciting to watch and be a part of, I believe I have skills to add to the revitalization effort.
But there’s a “But.” A big one, one that no one seems to be talking about yet. Detroit Public Schools are a mess and there are few proposed solutions (see this article about charters). City services are underfunded and can be unreliable. There are very few grocery stores within the city limits. There is a tenuous relationship between the suburbs and the city that doesn’t seem to exist as intensely in other urban areas of the country. And what about the community of people who live in Detroit, have lived there all along? Where are their voices? What is the balance between the efforts that need to be made to create and sustain a healthy, viable city and live the kind of life that I’d like to have?
What’s going to happen when all of these “hip,” “talented,” “creative” young folks who have moved to Detroit decide to have families? Where will they send their children to school? Who will bus them? As a public school veteran (and now employee), I believe in that system and do not want (and probably won’t be able to afford) to send my kids to a private school when the time comes. I’m not willing to sacrifice their education, so where does that leave me? I enjoy being able to ride my bicycle to the locally-owned grocery store a mile away any day of the week, to the farmer’s market on the weekends, to the pharmacy, etcetera. While this may be a luxury in some communities, we chose this area for that very privilege - to be close to the things we need. If you think about it, shouldn’t everyone be afforded that privilege? I know there are young families “making it” in Detroit. They can probably answer many of my questions but for now I’ll send them into the ether.
Patience. Time. Sweat. I know Rome wasn’t built in a day, and that Detroit hasn’t been the Detroit my parents knew in quite some time, and that we have to start somewhere. I only hope that some big-picture reality can make its way into the conversation: Schools that provide a comprehensive, up-to-date education and real-life skills; partnerships across city/suburb boundaries; sustainable industries with opportunities for professional growth; viable social services; accessible, healthy food for everyone, not just those who can afford it; safe neighborhoods.
I expect great things to happen in the city of Detroit over the next many years, and am inspired by my friends who have made the choice to live and work there. I’ll continue to frequent the restaurants, markets, galleries, bars, and cultural events that have kept us busy the last three years, but I’ll also continue to struggle over my own place and role within the city limits.

Katy,
ReplyDeleteI loved reading this! That challenge of making important decisions as we become more solid in our adulthood. I LOVE Detroit! Some of my best times in Michigan were there and I loved getting to the community in SW Detroit where I did one of my internships! I think Detroit is already becoming revitalized as I explore options with the possibility of moving to that area again. Let's talk soon!
Happy New Year!
T